Research indicates that digital formative assessment (DFA) has great potential to support more powerful student learning. Both researchers and educational professionals are increasingly interested in how digital technologies can enhance the ways teachers provide feedback to their students (example). The Assess@Learning literature review highlights different ways in which digital tools can enhance formative assessment practices.
Digital tools allow for teachers to collect rapid (real-time) feedback and to scaffold the next steps of their students’ learning at an appropriate level of difficulty. Collecting such rapid feedback can help teachers, for instance, to organise class discussions that respond to the different needs of each student.
Benefits of digital technology in DFA contexts
Consider a teacher wants to assess students’ reading comprehension. She asks students to read texts on a computer program. At the end of each section, the program asks students a multiple-choice question about the section. If the student chooses a wrong answer, the program provides an explanation why the answer is not correct and gives hints on where to find the correct answer. A study (Hooley & Thorpe, 2017) shows that students who used this program performed better at reading and comprehension than the students in the control group. This is only one example for where DFA can result in better learning outcomes.
Rapid, real-time feedback
Digital tools allow for rapid (real-time) feedback and scaffolding of next steps for learning at an appropriate level of difficulty.
Automatised, constructive feedback
Digital tools can help the teacher to collect feedback from all students at the same time and analyze the results quicker. Digital tools can also help with automatising feedback to typical responses that occur frequently.
Learning anytime, anywhere
With increasing access of learners to the Internet and mobile devices, digital tools can also support learners’ choices and learning ‘anytime, anywhere’, also helping them to design their own learning goals and strategies.
Enablers for the systematic uptake of DFA
Digital tools can create more time for learning and teaching, provide new opportunities for each student to participate and create a fun and engaging learning environment. DFA practices can be taken up by one teacher individually or by several colleagues, based on a whole school approach. To successfully implement DFA at classroom level, both schools and policy makers need to provide support. What enablers need to be put in place?
Challenges to the uptake of DFA
Establishing DFA as a new practice at school, all stakeholders can be more prepared by being aware of the challenges and how to meet them.
Students ideally need one device each as well as a stable internet connection both at school and at home. While access to digital devices at school and at home has grown significantly in recent years, it is not universal. Differences between regions, schools and urban and rural areas persist.
Using digital tools for assessment, both formative and summative, requires teachers, school heads and policy makers to consider how to ensure a secure and valid use of student data. Digital tools used with students need to be checked (e.g. where data is stored, for what purposes it is used and whether it is shared with third parties). Seen the quick pace at which new tools and apps become available, keeping track is not an obvious task.
Making sense of data
Teachers and students need to be able to interpret data on learning. Teachers should be able to aggregate results at the right level to obtain information on learning that teachers can communicate with students and colleagues and compare with the data collected at other situations and time points. Data from different educational sources need to be clear and comparable. However, it can be difficult to aggregate results at the right level to create exchangeable and comparable information about learning.
More data is used – with or without human intervention – to make decisions on student learning. While this opens exciting new possibilities, it also raises ethical questions. ‘Is every possible scenario desirable?’, ‘Do teachers and parents need to be able to see everything a student has done online and when (e.g. when a student completes homework)?’, and ‘What rules should govern the use of Artificial Intelligence in schools?’. Policy makers and school management need to consider these aspects and provide guidance to teachers.
What our participants say
“Digital tools enhance self-regulation, notably when they allow feedback or have responsive features (the digital platform reacts to the right and wrong answers of students with new activity proposals). They facilitate access to information by all stakeholders and they also increase student motivation.”
“In formative assessment, in addition the feedback provided by the teacher also pupils can self-evaluate themselves and their peers and learn from each other. Digital tools can make this process more engaging and fun. Digital tools can help creating exercises, through which students will learn by doing.”
“Digital tools help teachers collect simple data produced during teaching. These tools can visualise and present data in a form that can help teachers take decisions more efficiently regarding the planning and reformulation of their teaching. They also support the provision and exchange of learning materials between teachers.”